Current:Home > reviewsFeds want to hunt one kind of owl to save another kind of owl. Here's why. -Edge Finance Strategies
Feds want to hunt one kind of owl to save another kind of owl. Here's why.
View
Date:2025-04-12 09:35:33
Federal officials are planning to hire hunters with shotguns to exterminate tens of thousands of cat-sized barred owls in California and the Pacific Northwest as the birds "invade" from the east.
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service says barred owls represent an invasive threat to their cousins, Northern spotted owls, which are protected by the Endangered Species Act. Without action, officials said, the approximately 7,000 spotted owls left could become essentially extinct in the near future.
"We have been asked whether it is ethical to kill one species for the benefit of another," officials said in announcing their plan. "While we understand the concerns, the service has an obligation under ESA to recover listed species by addressing the threats to that species."
Why are officials planning to kill barred owls?
Federal wildlife officials say the barred owls, which are bigger, hungrier and better breeders, are moving into new territory and out-competing spotted owls.
The barred owls never used to live in the Pacific Northwest and California, but have moved west as European settlers cut down forests and disturbed East Coast ecosystems, officials said.
While barred owls can live in most places, spotted owls prefer old-growth and mature forests, which are also prized by loggers. Barred owls started being seen in the Pacific Northwest in the 1970s, federal officials said.
Officials said northern spotted owl populations in the northern half of the species’ range ‒ where barred owls have moved in most aggressively ‒ have dropped by more than 75% in 20 years.
Officials didn't put a price tag on their effort but said killing the estimated 60,000-100,000 barred owls across a portion of the West twice the size of Vermont would permit the spotted owl population to rise to about 8,400. Officials said their plans wouldn't threaten barred owls' overall existence because they are so widely distributed nationally.
What does the plan call for?
To create space for spotted owls to continue breeding, authorities would aim to kill about 20,000 barred owls in the first year, and then continue killing them for the next 30 years. Extermination would take place on federal and tribal lands, and private land with owners' permission.
Officials examined multiple alternatives, from relocating the barred owls to housing them in zoos or even dosing them with birth control. They also considered whether it would be better to trap and then euthanize the owls, but decided that hiring hunters was the most humane solution.
This isn't the first time officials have targeted the barred owls: starting in 2013, authorities killed them off in small test areas and found the spotted owl population of those areas stopped shrinking as a result.
How would it work?
Hunters armed with shotguns would deploy into the areas and play barred owl sounds. Because barred owls are territorial, they would investigate and be shot at close range. Officials said they would take precautions to avoid killing any spotted owls, but would also try to kill hybrid barred-spotted owls, which are just as aggressive as pure barred owls.
In more populated areas, officials might try to trap or net the owls instead.
Does anyone oppose this plan?
The environmental group Friends of Animals has been trying to block barred owl exterminations for years, arguing that while humans might have caused the conflict in the first place, it's not our role to fix it.
"While human-induced changes in animals habitats is certainly a bad thing, once they happen animals need to be able to sort it out—even if that means some species become threatened or endangered—without human interference," Michael Harris, the director of Friends of Animals’ Wildlife Law Program, said in a September statement. "We may have wrongly set the situation in motion, but we are only interfering further by trying to make it better for our 'preferred' species."
Haven't I heard of spotted owls before?
Spotted owls have long been part of an ongoing fight between Republicans and Democrats over the appropriate role of government, the Endangered Species Act and the economic consequences of protecting wildlife.
First protected by the ESA in 1990, the owls were then used in a series of lawsuits by environmental groups to shut down logging across large portions of the Pacific Northwest. Those logging battles continue to this day, with Republican presidents typically trying to expand logging at the expense of the owls, and Democrats trying to protect the owls, causing widespread economic harm to logging communities.
There's even a reference to them in the 2013 Leonardo DiCaprio movie "Wolf of Wall Street."
Environmental groups have accused logging companies of trying to protect barred owls because their presence keeps out spotted owls, allowing logging in areas that might otherwise be off-limits. Fish and Wildlife officials said they didn't expect the plan to kill barred owls to significantly change the amount of forest open for logging.
President Joe Biden recently unveiled a plan to protect large portions of forests favored by spotted owls.
veryGood! (959)
Related
- EU countries double down on a halt to Syrian asylum claims but will not yet send people back
- What does malignant mean? And why it matters greatly when it comes to tumors and your health.
- Brooke Shields trades heels for Crocs at 2024 Tony Awards
- Melinda French Gates on disrupting society with new philanthropic focus, finding her voice
- This was the average Social Security benefit in 2004, and here's what it is now
- 'Modern Family' stars reunite in WhatsApp ad discussing blue vs. green text bubble users
- 15-year-old girl shot to death hours before her middle school graduation, authorities say
- Stellantis recalling nearly 1.2 million vehicles to fix software glitch that disables rear camera
- Sonya Massey's father decries possible release of former deputy charged with her death
- Israeli military says it will begin a daily tactical pause to allow for humanitarian aid into southern Gaza
Ranking
- The Grammy nominee you need to hear: Esperanza Spalding
- Fisker files for bankruptcy protection, the second electric vehicle maker to do so in the past year
- First tropical storm warning of hurricane season issued as coastal Texas braces for possible flooding
- How Bridgerton Created Francesca's Queer Storyline With Gender-Swapped Character
- The FTC says 'gamified' online job scams by WhatsApp and text on the rise. What to know.
- A trial date has been set for a man charged in the kidnapping, killing of a Memphis school teacher
- An Oregon nurse faces assault charges that she stole fentanyl and replaced IV drips with tap water
- Biden immigration program offers legal status to 500,000 spouses of U.S. citizens. Here's how it works.
Recommendation
Apple iOS 18.2: What to know about top features, including Genmoji, AI updates
Shay Mitchell on traveling with kids, what she stuffs in her bags (including this salt)
Regan Smith sets American record at Olympic swimming trials in 100 back
In a first, one company is making three-point seatbelts standard on all school buses
Rams vs. 49ers highlights: LA wins rainy defensive struggle in key divisional game
USA Swimming named in explosive sexual abuse lawsuit involving former coach Joseph Bernal
Convicted killer of California college student Kristin Smart ordered to pay $350k in restitution
How hunters are helping researchers track the spread of tick-borne diseases